America, Again: A Long Rant
Cleaning Up After Cleveland (Andreas Kudacki, July 22, 2016;
nymag.com)
The Republicans have left Cleveland. There's little doubt that can-do Managers, the Owners and Choosers and Deciders, and the Belivers, were in control at the RNC, as they seem to be in control in so many places in our culture. Because Life is for The Strong, and the Tough, and the Competitive. And those with The Faith.
You Worker Bees, you "individual contributors" will just have to pull yourselves up by your own bootstraps. We will be Great again, and have Law and Order -- here in Merica -- or, you know, not. Thank everyone for coming!
________________________
Two Tales Of The City
Yesterday, I exited a subway car heading home from work at rush hour, turned right, and walked up a crowded
concourse. There was a wall to my immediate left and knots of other exiting passengers to my right. Suddenly, I
was face to face with a Caucasian male in his mid-20's, tall -- I'm well
over six feet; this guy was at least three inches taller -- thin, hair
cut close on the sides and in the middle puffed up in a modified Mohawk strip (as
if he had, uh, a Weasel On His Head).
What followed was textbook; each movement was an escalation. First, we looked -- no, we
stared
--at each other. Neither of us gave way. Even though by then there was
plenty of room around us, we each moved forward and slid past each
other, equally determined not to make it simple and as if daring the
other party to ratchet things up. Our arms inevitably brushed against each other, and we both pulled them away like yanking off a band-aid.
I
had walked a step or two, and turned; he was already
walking back. I stood where I was; he stopped inches from me. "You want
some?" he said. I was surprised, but not that much; I was aware that ratcheting up the confrontation was my fault as well as his:
They fought so fiercely because the stakes were so small. So, here we were and Quo Vadis?
Over the next second or so, I had two trains of thought. The first was something from another job life -- when an altercation turns into a confrontation, and the next step is
physical violence, that's not optimal. Keeping public order means, even if you have a disregard for your own
well-being, other people, innocent people, can get hurt. Your Macho takes a back seat.
The other consideration was -- this Guy. It was clear he was willing to make a physical threat
to a complete stranger, standing on a public transport platform during rush hour and In
These Times, when there are transit system police around -- I'd seen a K-9 patrol up ahead a few seconds before. I looked at the Guy,
careful not to lean forward or move my hands, and made an
Are you fucking kidding me? face. "Really?" I asked him.
"Really,"
he said -- and leaned forward. Without moving, I said, "Excuse Me."
Leaning forward a bit more, determined to count coup, he said, "Excuse
me. Have a nice day." Even without hearing his tone of voice, you can
decide whether or not he meant it.
____________________
Fast forward to
this afternoon: A bus in Kiddietown; another Caucasian guy in his twenties -- this one short and
slight, casually dressed, otherwise unremarkable -- drops a few papers as he
enters the bus, and begins cursing -- shouting, in fact; and it's quickly clear he's inordinately
upset about something which does not involve the bus, or anyone on it.
He stomps toward the
back of the bus, drops into a seat, and for the next block or so periodically shouts more curses, slapping the seat beside him. Almost everyone else on the bus goes into
You Are A Nutter And We Will Now Ignore You mode -- but, The Guy gets into it verbally with two Black males sitting behind him. Predictably, it escalates quickly.
"Hey!" Says the first man to The Guy, "Leave me
alone. Shutthefuck
up, man!" "
Fuck you man!!" shouts The Guy. "
I'll kick your fuckin' ass!!" The second man, who has a voice like James Earl Jones and is happy to project it, joins in: "Hey;
I ain't takin' that fuckin' bullshit off you, so
just shut - the - fuck - up!!"
The Guy braces himself in his seat and, with a real sense of timing, waits for a beat and then leans forward, staring at the two men, his face distorted with rage. "
Fuck you!!" he shouts, then adds, "You, you --
N_____ !!"
A hush falls over the entire bus, more felt than heard -- because
He said the N-word to two Black guys and we live in post Furgeson-Cleveland-Baltimore-Chicago-Mineapolis-et al. America -- and I'm thinking: man, wasn't I just here yesterday?
Meanwhile, the James Earl Jones Soundalike both
increases the volume
and lowers the pitch of his voice to a growl, another textbook stop on the road to
This Is Really Fucked Up. The Guy keeps shouting, a slight hesitancy in his voice now, as if understanding he'd crossed
The Fabled Line when using the n-word a block or so back. The two Black guys keep raising their voices in response.
Obligatory Mongo Photo In Middle Of Blog Terror
It's clear the confrontation has reached a binary decision point, and several other passengers call out to the driver, a Latino with a wrestler's build wearing Ray-Bans, to "do something". He doesn't, right away; I understand --
1.) Things can happen, all of them unpleasant by degrees;
2.) His Management supervisor and Union Foreman have advised there are liability issues; and
3.) "They don't pay me enough for
this shit, dude".
The driver finally comes to an official bus stop, halts the vehicle, then stands up, leans on a nearby pole and looks toward the altercation (all non-threatening, casual). "Hey -- hey; take it outside," he says to no one in particular, then appeals to reason and some generally-accepted social propriety: "Not on the bus, man."
After
a few seconds, when things could have gone in any direction, The Guy stands up and exits by the side door, shouting insults at the other men all the way. The men return them -- but it's all textbook now; The Guy has been the one to retreat.
Once he's off and the doors close, the bus begins to pull away. As it does, from the relative safety of Outside, The Guy performs another textbook maneuver: he begins screaming, ratcheting up his invective ("
Fuck you! N_____!! You N_____!!") and slaps the
side of the bus. JEJ-2, looking through the bus windows,
grins and flips him off; The Guy seems even more enraged and escalates again (
"I'll kill you, N_____ motherfucker!!"), but it's all for show, now, and everyone knows it. JEJ-2 grins once more and shouts, "Yeah; talk on, fuckhead"-- counting coup, also textbook.
A woman in her twenties at the front of the bus, holding a Prada purse and wearing a print sun dress, a Rolex and her own Ray-Bans, looked around at the other passengers and said with a giggle, "Well,
that was rully intense!" The remainder of the ride, by comparison, was uneventful.
____________________
The Brand, As If Anyone Had Forgotten
So why mention these things? (Dogs like stories, and are good at the details.) Because they exemplify a miserable trend in the broader culture; because I can't remember the last time I was in a confrontation (even one I helped create), as a civilian, which had real potential to become physically violent. And some of it mirrors what was on stage in Cleveland.
I'm part of an American demographic that doesn't encounter much real violence or intimidation, or police activity, on a regular basis. Mentioning my experiences to my friends prompted their own stories of confrontation and escalation. The general consensus: these altercations seem to happen more frequently, now --- and, they've increased over at least the past decade.
Most often, they happen when driving, shopping, and (bingo) commuting on mass transit. However, the most disturbing aspect to my friends is how easily things escalate: people seem more willing to push situations, which could easily be walked away from, right to the brink where real violence is possible.
Official studies show
the same trends, nationally, and in the same areas of social interaction. A
quick check of the ubiquitous Gogglemachine will show the same observations, the same consensus by multiple observers. It doesn't have to involve complete strangers. My experiences, and those of friends, involving bullying by managers in the workplace has also increased in the past decade.
Obligatory Cute Small Animal Photo In Middle Of Blog Rant
A few months ago, I'd called a manager of a national group about help in a project; he spent ten profanity-packed minutes accusing me of complaining about him to a vendor, crudely bullying me in any way he could.
This person has a reputation; I wasn't so surprised -- but I hadn't experienced him in that way, and I was knocked off balance. My responses -- interrupted constantly -- were factual; at some point, this person realized he was wrong in his accusations -- and like flipping a light switch, suddenly he sounded friendly, reasonable, behaving as if the previous ten minutes hadn't happened.
We both knew what he'd done -- and we both knew that even if I were to complain, because this person is labeled an "effective manager"; "he gets results"; there would be no repercussions. I have a number of similar stories about other managers, and executives; so do my friends who work in corporate businesses, even 'cool' tech companies with "new" working cultures -- and they're all depressingly the same.
These sorts of person are narcissistic, possibly sociopaths. They're certainly bullies -- and know that they are. They've found a niche in society which not only tolerates manipulation and mistreatment of other human beings, but rewards and promotes it. For them, it's a point of pride -- after all, they get results. And that's all that matters.
Weeks before he was assassinated, John F. Kennedy observed that one measure of a nation is through the individuals it upholds as heroes, worthy of emulation. Over the past few decades in America, the people we are told to venerate, our Best, are the Business Leaders. They're supposed to be what we should want our children to grow up to become.
I don't think we'd want to leave our children alone with them for thirty seconds. But the promise of wealth and success through a life spent in corporate business is what our children are being told is the highest expression of our culture, and the behaviors of these 'leaders' are what they need to adopt in order to reach that wealth, success and self-fulfillment.
_________________________
A long time ago, a cartoon posed the question, "What was the result of America's experience in Vietnam, and the attendant politics at home?" The correct answer was, "A deterioration of secular and spiritual priorities!" American culture is fraying badly under the weight of too many changes -- just the last ten include mass shootings, terrorism; The Crash; media outlets (Murdoch; Limbaugh, Wiener, Beck; O'Reilly) dumping human waste on our culture, 24-7. Our 'entertainment' almost universally involves violence.
The real wonder is that people aren't
more uncivil to each other, or that overtime parking doesn't invoke the death sentence.
_________________________
Trump: A Symptom
This week we watched (some of) the antics at the
Republican Convention, the Trump campaign's themes delivered
by most of the speakers -- except Grand Turtlebear Greg Stillson,
and Herr Doktor Carson, Exorcist and Fearless Vampire Killer, who seemed
to have additional messages of hope and faith
and eternal punishment in the fire the fire the fire for us all. And, of course,
we heard The Donald.
Additional Obligatory Animal Photo
There was nothing new in what he said
Thursday night (though its delivery was less his trademark stream-of-consciousness)
-- but I found myself asking
How the hell did we come to this? That this stupid bully became their candidate?? It was as if someone had reanimated
Fr. Charles Coughlin from the 1930's, George Wallace of the 1960's, or even
George Lincoln Rockwell. Trump appeared no different or better than any of the narcissistic bullies I've worked with or for in my lifetime. One difference between his campaign and Hillary's -- Trump says that he speaks for the angry Americans, the ones who want to "take it all back".
His campaign depends on tapping the kind of inchoate rage that we see or experience on the street, or at work. If Trump were to win, it would mean a period of social and political dislocation in America which no one in memory has experienced. I could make a joke about a similarity with H.P. Lovecraft's return of Chtulu and the Old Ones, but in fact nobody knows where it would all lead.
That said, I still believe Trump can't win. If how a person uses language is a good gauge of how they conceptualize and navigate the world, then Trump is too scattered and impulsive -- my Dog's nose tells me he can't run an effective team, and won't run a good ground game. And, there aren't enough of his brand of conservative to go to the polls for him on November 8th. He can't win by sheer weight of numbers. He'll lose.
But, this contest will be played in the media as a close race. The assumption of office by
President Hillary, The Inevitable One, will seem so very close (until the numbers come in) -- and Her victory will provide the consistency of a certain narrative about our history, a return to normal.
But Hillary is about the values of Business, too. When Hillary trotted out Tim Kane as her Veep, he spoke to a crowd and
said, "America has never been about fear... it's been about bravery, and
imagination, and
doing whatever it takes to get the job done! [applause]." Hillary described him as "a Progressive who believes in
getting the job done" (Emphasis in the original delivery).
Additional Obligatory Stimpy Face Photo
It's my expectation Hillary will assist in wiring America into a global system which will free business and banking from being responsible to the laws of individual nations -- environmental regulations; banking laws, trade laws. It will be an advantage capitalism has never had in history, making corporate business the single most important human activity. And it will continue the stratification of society, globally, into corporate Managers -- and everyone else, who will work for them, to earn money to buy products and services.
We'll still continue to be told a comforting narrative -- about America's uniqueness, independence and values, and it's place in the world. Frankly, Hillary's narrative is just a little softer than Trump's story of American greatness; only the wrapper is different. But to global Business, America is just one more place with resources and a population that can be bought, one more market where things can be sold. We can play our pretend politics, so long as we don't get in the way of the grownups, managing large-scale operations for profit.
________________________________
Without belaboring the obvious, it isn't surprising that so many people (including myself) are acting like badly-wired rats. The post-WW2 world's politics, ideologies, technologies; its commerce and wealth, all made major shifts in just one generation.
There had been a Cold War, and the possibility of a hot one, but also stability -- many regional players and ideologies (including those religious) were kept in check by the East-versus-West balance of power. No more.
It's been decades of pressure; the cycles of change happen more quickly, and the world appears to be changing in unpredictable ways. The trends being presented by these changes appear to indicate that the world is a Box Full Of Bad Crazy, Looking For A Way Out. And that The Fix Is In.
People are frightened about the future, and fear can easily flip into anger. Most people have some unresolved conflicts; others have years of badly-wired resentments and painful memories; still more have PTSD (thanks for the War, Lil' Boots!). This election season will be something to watch (I'd buy the Good Popcorn, but don't fire it up just yet) but the presidency of
Hillary The Inevitable will not provide America what it needs to heal itself. I don't think even Ted Cruz and Benny Carson's jesus™ could do that.
Try not to piss anyone off in public.
________________________________
Trumpwarbler. Doubling Down
Trumpwarbler. Doubling Down
